I have used this as a stain preventer in the past and it seems to work well, although it's hard to judge the effectiveness of a product that is preventing something until it doesn't work. When I opened my pool this year I had a brownish yellow stain a foot wide around the entire pool. It is the first time I have encountered this. While this product is primarily for preventing stains, the directions on the bottle say this will remove stains if used in higher concentration, so I purchased two bottles for my 20,000 gallon pool and followed the directions precisely. The stain seems to have lightened a little, but it is still there. Directions say a second dose may be necessary, but I'm reluctant to spend another $30 to find out if a second dose will eliminate the stain. I did try a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser on one section of the stain and it did seem to remove it pretty well. It will take some work, but I will try that before buying more expensive chemicals. Products effective on some stains may not be on others. It depends on what is causing the stain, so try to figure that out before buying expensive chemical solutions.6/21/15 Update To Review - The stain did continue to lighten, but I was able to remove it completely by going around the pool with a Mr. Clean Magic Eraser. Don't know if this will work on other pool stains, but with the combination of Stain Away and the Magic Eraser, I was able to eliminate my stain. I may have been able to do it with the Magic Eraser alone, but it likely would have been a little more work to do so. If I get the a similar pool stain again, I will try the Magic Eraser because it is a cheap solution, but wouldn't hesitate to use the Stain Away again if necessary.EventuallyWorksWorked for meproduct did what it said it wouldPleased with results for removal, now it's maintenance time.Pool stains. It didn’t work very well.We were sold a used and very dirty pool. Scrubbed for weeks before we finally searched the internet for a good product, this cleaned it without scrubbing!Deciding whether to purchase again as some stains look lighter. The directions indicate that more than one treatment may be necessary. I want to find a product that removes the metal stains in order to have my pool crystal clear.